Mon Mar 16, 2009 11:39 pm
It's from a case involving a guy from Québec, he fought the ban and the immigration court ruled in his favour, IIRC he was given a ban at Derby Line. I'm sure if you talk to someone from AILA they're familiar with it.
CBP and USCIS use a formula for calculating the length of the ban based on the amount of time you overstayed, the court ruled that calculation cannot be used in relation to Canadian visitors, which effectively means they can't be banned merely for overstaying as a visitor, provided they didn't violate their status in some other way, e.g. by working.
They can still deny you from entry for a previous overstay though if the inspecting officer thinks that means you don't have non-immigrant intent, so it's a bit of a grey area because if you're repeatedly denied entry then it's effectively the same as a ban anyway.
In addition, they still ban Canadian citizens, people have been on here who have been banned for overstaying in B-2, but there is caselaw that can be used to challenge the ban.
Steve.