Posted: Fri Jul 06, 2007 10:01 pm-
I had the same problem. After over a year in the US paying utilities on time, I bought a house. I thought a credit card would be easy at that point, but no dice. Utilities doesn't get you a credit rating, only loans do. So what I should have done is taken out a small loan at my local bank and paid it back immediately.
Anyway, six months into my house and I still couldn't get a credit card. I got loads of junk mail with "pre-approved" credit card offers. I tried them, and they turned me down anyway. The only one that didn't was a Mastercard, which thrilled me, until I found they wanted around $400 in fees the first year. I told them forget it, and it's because of those scammers that I will never get a Mastercard.
I talked to a friend who worked for Capital One and he said I was a "thin file", which means I had no credit history. In fact, it's better to have bad credit than no credit.
I called Equifax and TransUnion and asked them to show my Canadian credit on my US file. They said they can't do that, but for an extra $10 a credit card company can always check my Canadian file. So I tried that with a few credit card sales twits and they couldn't be bothered. They follow a script, and checking Canadian credit isn't on the script.
However, banks are willing to do this for a mortgage or a loan.
Then I found that AMEX has a "special credit" area that will grant you a US Amex if you have a Canadian one, which I did. I called them, and got my new card -- no problem. I wish I knew that 2 years earlier. The reason Amex does this, and Visa and Mastercard won't, is because Amex does their own credit card sales. The rest farm them out to sales channels, who are lazy and (in the case of Mastercard) can rip you off.
So until you have at least a year's credit on the books, that's probably your best option. Get a Canadian Amex and then an American one. In the meantime, get a small loan from your local bank and pay it back a month later. In a year, you'll have a dozen credit card offers per week, like the rest of us.